One of the delights (and challenges) of Halloween is deciding how to dress up on the big day. Should I be scary? Saucy? Funny? Downright bloody and gross?

I essentially decided to leave it up to you, dear readers, and Goodwill. I saw this fun costume generator online from Goodwill, so my daughter Lily and I popped in Goodwill to see what they had in stock.

I was BLOWN away at the selection: Not only did they have masks and costumes, but they had pet costumes, really great Halloween home decor, pumpkin carving/jack-o-lantern kits and lots of make up, wigs, teeth, etc. They were all brand new in the packages at crazy discounted prices.

Here's just part of it:

Inside Goodwill's Halloween Haven

I put together several options and offered up an online poll earlier this month:

1) Happy Clown

Angel, Townsquare Media

2) Swashbuckling Pirate

Angel, Townsquare Media

3) Zombie Standard Poodle

Angel, Townsquare Media

4) Mardi Gras Police Officer

Angel, Townsquare Media

5) Alien

Angel, Townsquare Media

Here what everyone had to say:

So, I'll be blending looks (and maybe handing out beads) as a Mardi Gras police officer.

And, whether you're looking for the final touches to you costume or just getting started, you should head down to Goodwill. Online, they have a Halloween Look Book, online costume generator, DIY tips and much more here. It's truly a great place to let your imagination run wild!